Introduction
If you’re in the market for a new roof, you’ve likely come across the ongoing debate between asphalt shingles and metal roofing. While both have their place in residential construction, many homeowners continue to choose asphalt shingles—and for good reason.
From affordability and installation ease to aesthetic flexibility and repair simplicity, asphalt shingles offer a well-rounded package that’s hard to beat. Despite the hype around metal roofs, asphalt remains the most popular roofing material in North America.
In this article, we’ll explore the benefits of asphalt shingles vs metal roof, and why they might be the right fit for your home—today, tomorrow, and years down the line.
Benefits of Asphalt Shingles vs Metal Roof
When it comes to practicality, price, and appearance, asphalt shingles have stood the test of time. They blend traditional charm with modern manufacturing improvements, giving homeowners a reliable, cost-effective option.
Let’s dive into the core reasons why asphalt shingles continue to dominate the residential roofing market—and why you might want to choose them over metal.
Cost-Effective and Budget-Friendly
One of the most compelling reasons homeowners choose asphalt shingles is cost. Asphalt is hands-down the most affordable roofing option for most residential homes.
- Asphalt shingles cost: $3–$5 per square foot
- Metal roofs cost: $7–$14+ per square foot
This significant price difference can save thousands of dollars on a full roof installation—especially on larger homes.
And it’s not just about materials. Asphalt shingle installation is faster and easier, meaning lower labor costs as well.
For first-time homeowners, flippers, or families on a budget, asphalt provides a high-quality solution without breaking the bank.
Easier and Faster to Install
Asphalt shingles are well-known for their quick and uncomplicated installation. Roofers are already familiar with the process, which translates to:
- Shorter project timelines
- Fewer complications
- Lower installation fees
In contrast, metal roofing often requires specialized tools, underlayment, and extra planning—especially for standing seam or custom metal profiles.
If you need a roof replacement done fast and efficiently, asphalt shingles shine bright.
Wide Variety of Styles and Colors
Think asphalt shingles are boring? Think again.
Today’s asphalt shingles come in:
- Architectural, dimensional, and luxury varieties
- Dozens of colors and finishes
- Textures that mimic slate, wood, and tile
This level of customization and curb appeal is hard to find elsewhere. You can match your roof to your home’s design with ease—something that’s not as simple with metal roofing’s more industrial or contemporary look.
Whether you’re going for modern, traditional, rustic, or high-end, asphalt shingles provide more visual flexibility.
Simple Repairs and DIY Potential
Every roof will need repairs at some point—but not all repairs are created equal.
Asphalt shingles are easier and cheaper to repair than metal roofing. If a shingle gets damaged:
- You can replace just one or two shingles
- Repairs can often be done by a handy homeowner
- Local roofers are readily available and experienced
Metal roofing, on the other hand, may require full panel replacements, specialized equipment, and often professional help—even for small fixes.
For homeowners who value low-maintenance AND self-sufficiency, asphalt makes the better choice.
Lightweight and Structurally Friendly
Asphalt shingles are lightweight—typically 2 to 4 pounds per square foot. That makes them ideal for older homes or structures not designed to bear heavy loads.
By contrast, some metal roofing systems (especially copper or tile-look metals) can add significant weight and may require additional framing or bracing.
If your home’s structural integrity is a concern, or you’re looking for minimal disruption during installation, asphalt is the safest, most adaptable option.
Good Performance in Moderate Climates
In regions without extreme weather—think moderate rainfall, limited snow, and mild summers—asphalt shingles perform beautifully.
They:
- Withstand average wind and rain conditions
- Are fire-resistant with proper underlayment
- Last 15–30 years with good maintenance
And while metal roofing may last longer, asphalt’s lifespan matches most people’s time in a single home. That makes it a cost-efficient solution for many families.
Tried-and-True Warranty Protection
Many asphalt shingles come with solid warranties, including:
- 20–30 year manufacturer coverage
- Some “lifetime” guarantees on premium products
- Optional enhanced warranties with certified installers
You’ll also find more roofing contractors certified by major asphalt shingle brands, which increases peace of mind and simplifies any warranty claims.
Aesthetic Compatibility with Neighborhoods
Homeowners’ associations (HOAs) often have guidelines about roof appearance—and asphalt shingles tend to check the right boxes.
Metal roofs can look too modern or too industrial for traditional neighborhoods, while asphalt shingles blend effortlessly with nearby homes, maintaining consistency and appeal.
If you want to preserve neighborhood charm or sell your home in a suburban market, asphalt shingles can actually increase buyer interest.
Myths About Asphalt Shingles (Debunked)
Let’s clear the air.
- “Asphalt shingles are low quality.” Modern fiberglass-reinforced shingles are tough, durable, and resistant to algae, fire, and wind.
- “They all look the same.” With designer and architectural options, asphalt shingles now offer as much variety as metal.
- “They’re bad for the environment.” Many manufacturers now offer recyclable shingles and cool roof options that reflect heat.
The asphalt shingle industry has evolved dramatically, and it continues to improve year over year.
FAQs
Do asphalt shingles last as long as metal roofs?
Not quite, but they last 15–30 years, which aligns with how long most homeowners stay in one house.
Are asphalt shingles cheaper than metal roofs?
Yes. Asphalt is significantly cheaper upfront and easier to install and repair.
Can I install asphalt shingles over my old roof?
Yes, in many cases. Always consult your roofer and check local building codes.
Are asphalt shingles energy efficient?
Certain light-colored shingles and reflective variants offer decent heat resistance, though not quite as much as metal.
Do asphalt shingles perform well in storms?
Modern shingles have impact and wind resistance ratings, with some built to withstand winds up to 130 mph.
Is there a “best” brand of asphalt shingles?
Brands like GAF, CertainTeed, and Owens Corning are industry leaders with great warranties and performance ratings.
Conclusion
In the conversation of asphalt shingles vs metal roof, the humble shingle holds its ground—firmly.
If you value:
- Budget-friendliness
- Fast installation
- Classic style
- Easy repairs
Then asphalt shingles are the perfect blend of performance, appearance, and practicality. They’ve protected homes for decades—and for millions of homeowners, they’ll keep doing exactly that.
